5 Tips for When Your Spells Aren’t Working

When your spells aren’t working, it’s easy to get frustrated, give up or doubt your abilities.  

But magic is really a spiritual discipline and the lessons that it teaches you when your spells aren’t working are at least as important and valuable as the ones you learn through successful spell casting.

So today, we’re going to talk about what to do and think about when you just can’t seem to get your broomstick headed in the right direction.

How do you know your spell isn’t working?

Start with this fundamental question.  

Is your spell really not working, or is it just not working the way you want it to?

For example, you cast a money spell and $100 bills aren’t suddenly growing on the tree in your backyard.  But you just got a job offer that pays 20% more than your current salary.   Is your spell really not working? 

Or did you just decide that you’d rather not commute an extra 30 minutes a day?

If it’s the second one, then your spell is working, and magic is teaching you a lesson:  Money isn’t everything, and you just learned what you aren’t willing to do for it.  That’s a good thing to know about yourself.

Are you supporting your work in the mundane world?

You can throw all the fairy dust you want to at a problem, but if you don’t do the heavy lifting to support your spell in the mundane world, you’re wasting your efforts (and your fairy dust).

This is among the most common witchcraft mistakes.

It’s not that magic will never work if you take this approach.  But it’s much less effective.  Kind of like trying to lose weight by working out but not changing your diet.

Does this feel like a bad idea?

Modern spell craft is very much about focusing your intentions.  In order for this approach to be effective, those intentions must be clear, purposeful, and whole-hearted.

That last one is important.

If you have cast a spell that, in your core, you don’t feel exactly right about, that may be your problem.

To be clear, I don’t really think there are many spells that are inherently immoral or wrong.  But there are situations where a particular magical approach might be wrong for you.  

For example, if you cast a love spell to bring back an ex, there’s an excellent chance that person left your life for a reason.  And your subconscious, or the universe, or whomever you want to hold responsible, knows that.

So when you cast a spell with that deep, wiser knowledge that it’s not a good idea, it’s kind of like firing a gun with no bullets.

Try a different approach.

If none of the above apply to you, consider trying a different approach.

For example, instead of using a spell poppet for a love spell, consider experimenting with love spell cookies or potion magic.

Sometimes, reaching your magical goals is simply a matter of changing strategies.

What it probably isn’t.

A lot of people, especially beginners, think their spells aren’t working because they did something “wrong” in the sequence or process of casting the spell itself.

Like using nutmeg instead of cinnamon.  Or saying the incantation wrong, or not saying it enough times.

Unless you’re experimenting with reconstructionism, historical spells, or something very culturally specific, modern witchcraft can’t really be done wrong.

Meaning that the tools you use, the order you do things, and the conditions you do them under are all intended to create a frame of mind, 

A spell is more like a recipe than a science experiment.  It’s fine to swap out ingredients, change the order you cut the vegetables or use a mixing bowl instead of a serving dish.  

You still end up with the same meal.

Are you just getting started on the path of witchcraft?  Check out Moody Moons’ complete introductory course, Witchcraft 101:  Discovering the Magic in You.

---

Sources & References

Claims Based on Documented Sources

• Magic as spiritual discipline: Documented in contemporary witchcraft philosophy and practice
• Money spells: Documented in contemporary spell craft traditions
• Love spells: Documented in historical and contemporary witchcraft practices
• Spell poppets: Documented in folk magic and contemporary witchcraft
• Love spell cookies: Documented in kitchen witch practices
• Potion magic for romance: Documented in herbal and kitchen witchcraft traditions
• Common witchcraft mistakes (beginning practitioners): Documented in contemporary witchcraft instruction
• Love spell ethics and consent considerations: Documented in modern witchcraft discourse
• Nutmeg and cinnamon correspondences: Documented in herbal magic
• Spell casting methodology: Documented in contemporary witchcraft practice
• Reconstructionism and historical spell work: Documented in historical witchcraft studies
• Modern witchcraft flexibility regarding ingredients and process: Documented in contemporary witchcraft teaching
• Recipe-based spell approach: Documented metaphor in contemporary magical instruction

Claims Based on Personal Practice & Experience

• 20+ years of modern pagan community observation (Lumina Indigo)
• Direct experience with spell casting and troubleshooting (Lumina Indigo)
• Personal understanding of intention-setting and spell work effectiveness (Lumina Indigo)
• Professional tarot reading and divination experience (Lumina Indigo)
• Kitchen witch culinary magic expertise (Lumina Indigo)
• Observation of common spell casting challenges among practitioners (Lumina Indigo)
• Professional spell casting review and editorial expertise (Tina Caro)

Recommended Reading

• Contemporary witchcraft practice guides for beginners
• Moody Moons course: “Witchcraft 101: Discovering the Magic in You”
• Works on intention-setting and manifestation in magical practice
• Kitchen witchcraft and spell variation resources

About the Author

Written by Lumina Indigo (Moody Moons), founder in 2012, specializing in in-depth research on modern spirituality. With 20+ years of pagan community experience, Lumina is a professional tarot reader and kitchen witch. Reviewed by Tina Caro.

Note

This article presents practical troubleshooting for spell work based on contemporary witchcraft practice and personal experience. The five key points address common reasons spells may not produce expected results: (1) redefining what “working” means, (2) combining magical and mundane effort, (3) examining internal doubt or misalignment, (4) trying alternative approaches, and (5) understanding that procedural perfection isn’t required. Modern witchcraft emphasizes flexibility and personal intuition over rigid rules. Practitioners should note that magic complements but does not replace practical action, professional guidance, or personal responsibility. Spell effectiveness depends on clarity of intention, emotional alignment, consistent practice, and willingness to combine magical work with real-world effort toward goals.